Hegemonic stability theory hst is a theory of international relations, rooted in research from the fields of political science, economics, and history. But how then is international order to be maintained, if this still requires a managerial role on the part of the great powers. In other words, hegemonic values and the social experience of the. Hegemony is mostly used to refer to relationships between different nations or countries. According to gilpin, a hegemonic war is characterized by three features. The theory of hegemonic war the origin and prevention of major. According to gilpin, the theory of hegemonic war founds its origins in.
Long cycles, or long waves, offer interesting perspectives on global politics by permitting the careful exploration of the ways in which world wars. We conclude by o ering general predictions on the likelihood of hegemonic wars and extracting policy implications for u. Geller the scholars most frequently credited with development of the quantitative empirical study of war include frederick adams woods, alexander baltzly, pitirim a. Classical marxist theory, of course, stresses economic position as the strongest predictor of social differences. Gramscis theory of cultural hegemony linkedin slideshare. Before the advent of nuclear weapons, the work of theory in the mili.
American political science and international relations theory during the cold war. Robert gilpin, the theory of hegemonic war, journal of. First, the presence of a dominant actor will lead to the provision of a stable international regime of free trade more broadly, hegemons provide leadership for the emergence of international regimes in various issueareas. Hegemony pronounced with a soft or hard g is the power of one group over other groups.
Everything can be explained by expected utility theory cooperation, lack of. The theory of hegemonic stability is important in understanding the stability and instability in the international political economy. From this point of view, i will argue that regional hegemonic system has multiple negative poles imperialismdominance on the one hand and neglectindifference on the other hand. Hegemonic decline and hegemonic war revisited request pdf. The us, however, has not acted as the sole hegemon since the 1970s and the main financial and monetary institutions are. The limits of hegemonic stability theory international. According to the theory of hegemonic stability, the role played by a hegemonic power is very importance in creating stability in international politics and economy. In the past, there was a dominant communication theory that explains the relationship between media and the public. This describes how states use cultural institutions to maintain power in capitalist societies. Section 4 applies our theory to the cases of wwii in europe and the paci c. To c a r r y out this t a s k, it is n e c e s s a r y t o make thucydides ideas more systematic, expose his basic assumptions, and u n d e r s t a n d his a n a l y t i c a l method. Today it is especially associated with the italian marxist and revolutionary antonio gramsci 1891 1937, for whom it is the core and organizing concept of his social and political ideas. Italian communism and german conservativism in the interwar years. Hst indicates that the international system is more likely to remain stable when a single nationstate is the dominant world power, or hegemon.
Thucydides theory of hegemonic war causes of war and peace wars are the result of changes to power balance, or. Thucydides theory of hegemonic war the essential idea embodied in thucydides theory of hegemonic war is that fundamental changes in the international system are the basic determinants of such wars. It can be applied to various situations with the same meaning. Understanding hegemony in international relations theories. Wars are the result of changes to power balance, or unstable balance of power. The rise and decline of hegemonic states remains a central concern of scholars and policy makers. Global trade reached its greatest levels in the years just preceding world war i, when many european nations had 5. Wars are the result of changes to power balance, or unstable balance of. Hegemony, the dominance of one group over another, supported by legitimating norms and ideas. Hegemony in international society ian clark oxford. Can international legitimacy operate even in a deformed balance of power, and when there is only one dominant state.
Through a quantitative analysis looking at both american and british hegemonic governance, it was discovered that in both cases there is a strong negative association between. Thompson, the capitalist worldeconomy paradigm oflmmanuel wallerstein, and robert gilpins theory of hegemonic war and change. At the washington naval conference, france, great britain, italy, japan, and the united states agreed. This paper examines hegemonic stability theory, the concept in international relations that an assertive hegemon can act as a stabilizing force in the international system. Sometimes it is used as almost the equivalent of ideological domination. Proponents point to the period after wwi, at which point america returned to isolationism, and the return to great power war in wwii as an example of what happens when there is no hegemon to lead the system. With the end of cold war, the united states, the frontier of theoretical studies, began to search for a new vision in order to form a new conceptual basis based on the realism to bolster its hegemonic dominance. To be sure, most international relations scholars long ago abandoned the quest for a simple causal. In this article, robert gilpin discusses the general dynamics of international relations, which thucydides had discovered. Basically its the power or control that one state holds over others, usually others in the same. This might be direct dominance, such as through military might, but may be indirect dominance, such as when a nation can dictate the terms of trade to its advantage. Hegemonic challenge is not the same thing as counterhegemony. The theory of hegemonic stability and embedded liberalism the case of the bretton woods system. The theory in essence antonio gramsci is best known for his theory of cultural hegemony.
Often conflated with organskis theory of power transition, it is referred to as hegemonic stability theory. Within the subdiscipline of international political economy ipe, the genesis of the concept of hegemony or leadership has two sources. The basic proposition of the theory, that an open or liberal international economic order requires the existence of a hegemonic or dominant power, retains wide support in the field and beyond. The downside of this situation became apparent after the terrorist strikes on the world trade center, in 2001. Hegemony is the political, economic, or military predominance or control of one state over others. Gilpin focuses on how the international order emerges from hegemonic wars, is forged and upheld by dominant states, and how it comes under pressure from rising powers. The stability of the international system requires a single dominant state to articulate and enforce the rules of interaction among the most important members of the system to be a hegemon, a state must have three attributes. Hegemony is dominance and subordination in the field of relations structured by power hall, 1985.
Hegemonic stability theory been the focus of substantial scholarly attention in recent years. Definitions and concepts of hegemony definition of hegemony hegemony to the domain of one entity above others of the same type is called. A conceptual framework, the hegemonic triangle, identifies a hegemonic approach to customersupplier relationships involving dominance, mastery and authority. Hegemonic war in this article, robert gilpin discusses the general dynamics of international relations, which thucydides had discovered. In 1921, the united states convened a disarmament negotiation among the naval powers of the pacific. Hegemonic stability theory argues that a hegemon helps maintain both economic and political stability in the international order. Hegemony hegemony is one of the most elusive concepts in marxist discussions of ideology. The theory of hegemonic stability and embedded liberalism. Assumptions of the theory underlying thucydides view. Gilpin focuses on how the international order emerges from hegemonic wars, is forged and upheld by dominant states, and how it comes under. This paper seeks to produce a critique of neorealist hegemonic stability theory hst through a historical comparison of britain in the nineteenth century and the united states after 1945.
Hst assumes that britain in the nineteenth century and the united states after 1945 have both been hegemons, initiating and maintaining identical policies. The analytic discourse of cultural hegemony is important to research and synthesis in anthropology, political science, sociology, and cultural studies. Thus, the fall of an existing hegemon or the state of no hegemon diminishes the stability of the. In a nutshell, long cycle theory describes the connection between war cycles. The structure of the system or distribution of power among the states in the system can be stable or unstable. Consequently, hegemonic wars are systemwide wars where what is at. The term is often used as shorthand to describe the dominant position of a particular set of ideas and their associated tendency to become commonsensical, thereby. International relations theory has not taken that problem. Backlash against liberalism belief in economic nationalism protectionism.
Hegemonic stability theory hst is a theory of international relations, rooted in research from. Conventionally, hegemony has been perceived as a threat to international society. The essential idea embodied in thucydides theory of hegemonic war is. Issues of hegemony, hegemonic power, benign and malign hegemons, and so on returned to the top of the ir agenda. Anderson ranges across many settings, including the russian labour movement at the turn of the 20th century. The return to protectionism started in the latter part of the 19th century, when britain, despite the beginning of a decline in its relative power, was still the hegemon. The theory of hegemonic stability the theory of hegemonic stability probably remains the most popular and influential theory in the subject of international political economy today. Section 3 formalizes the theory through a gametheoretic model. Hegemony simple english wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Sorokin, quincy wright, lewis fry richardson, karl deutsch, and j.
The origin and prevention of major wars edited by robert i. The transition from british to american hegemony by kori schake, published by harvard university press in november 2017. Conversely, the absence of a hegemon is associated with disorder and undesirable outcomes. Hegemonic stability theory is a theory that attempts to explain changes in the degree to which the international political economy is open or restricted on the basis of the power relations between the major states in the world system. Originally a theory of international political economy, hst argues that a liberal economic order and stability occur when there is a single dominant power that is, a hegemon.
An economic theory of hegemonic war semantic scholar. It is called stimulus response theory or sr theory, and it said that the media had a very powerful and direct impact on the people watching tv or reading a newspaper. Thucydides theory of hegemonic war and contemporary varia tions of t h a t t h e o r y. Thus, the fall of an existing hegemon or the state of no hegemon diminishes the stability of the international system. The following is an adapted excerpt from safe passage. Cultural hegemony has philosophically influenced eurocommunism, the social sciences, and the activist politics of socially liberal and progressive politicians. Hegemonic stability theory hst is a hybrid theory that draws on the realist, liberal and historical structuralist perspectives. It is at once political, economic, and ideological. According to robert keohane, the theory of hegemonic stability defines hegemony as preponderance of material resources. Neorealist hegemonic stability theory history essay. The starting point of hegemonic stability theory is the presence of a single dominant state. Historical experience of a society lessons from past wars. From traditional to institutionalized hegemony alison bailin 2 abstract both hegemonic stability and institutionalism attempt to explain the stability or continuity of the liberal economic order over the postwwii period.
1279 952 704 1266 566 1021 1086 1512 491 54 951 925 342 505 1529 276 518 164 902 1181 160 266 429 96 573 499 174 715 352 314 1066 648 157 634 512 306 416 1195 354 52 289